Different tracheotomy tube diameters influence diaphragmatic effort and indices of weanability in difficult to wean patients.

OBJECTIVE To determine the effects of different tracheotomy tube sizes on diaphragm effort and weanability indices. METHODS Ten tracheotomized and difficult to wean subjects were randomized to 2 T-piece trials, with different tracheotomy tube diameters: inner diameters 8 mm and 6.5 mm. Diaphragm pressure-time product per min. (PTP(di/min)), lung compliance and resistance (C(L) and R(L)), breathing pattern, tension-time index of the diaphragm (TT(di)), and the ratio of breathing frequency to tidal volume (f/V(T)) were recorded. In an in vitro model, the flow-pressure relationship was measured using the 2 tracheotomy tubes and 2 endotracheal tubes of the same diameter. RESULTS The use of a smaller diameter resulted in an increase of PTP(di) (337.63 ± 194.35 cm H(2)O · s/min vs 263.28 ± 156.23 cm H(2)O · s/min for 6.5 mm and 8 mm, respectively, P = .004) and R(L) (16.74 ± 8.10 cm H(2)O · s/min vs 11.72 ± 7.88 cm H(2)O · s/min, respectively, P = .008). Both weanability indices were also significantly higher using the smaller tube: f/V(T) 93.32 ± 20.91 vs 77.06 ± 19.26 for 6.5 mm and 8 mm, respectively, P < .02; TT(di) 0.09 ± 0.052 vs 0.08 ± 0.04, respectively, P < .02. In vitro measurements confirmed that the resistances were higher with the smaller diameter and similar between the tracheotomy tubes and the endotracheal tubes of the same diameters. CONCLUSIONS In tracheotomized difficult to wean subjects the decrease of the tracheotomy tube size was associated with an increased PTP(di), f/V(T), and TT(di), that were otherwise normal, using a higher diameter. The in vitro study showed that the resistances increased similarly for tracheotomy tube and endotracheal tube, decreasing the diameter and increasing the flows.